Sermon:
Mark 1:4-11; Acts 19:1-7
I feel for those believers Paul met in Ephesus, who must have suddenly felt as though they'd stumbled into a theology exam. ‘Did you receive the Holy Spirit when you became believers?' Paul demands of them. ‘We've not even heard there is a Holy Spirit,' they reply, nervously - you can imagine them thinking, ‘What on earth is he talking about? And why did he have to pick us to cross-examine?' Paul carries on regardless. ‘Well, what baptism did you have?' Ah - a question they can answer. ‘It was John who baptised us,' they answer, hoping that's OK.
Now Paul's got somewhere to start from. ‘Well, if you were baptised by John, you'd better know what he said about Jesus. You remember he was always looking out for someone who would come after him, someone greater than him whose sandals he wasn't worthy to untie?' ‘Yes,' the believers in Ephesus admit, ‘he was always going on about that. We wondered who he meant.' And now Paul's well away. ‘John was talking about Jesus!' he exclaims. ‘The Messiah, the one we were all waiting for. And I can tell you some amazing things about him...' And off Paul goes, talking nineteen to the dozen.
Well, that makes sense of it all to the Ephesians. If Jesus is the one their master John was waiting for, of course they should get baptised in Jesus' name. But their baptism gives them more than they may have anticipated, for as Paul prays for them, they begin to experience God's Spirit in new and totally unexpected ways, causing them to praise God enthusiastically and to see and speak out about God's work in Ephesus - as the jargon has it, they were ‘speaking in tongues and prophesying'.
Fast-forward several centuries, to my year out studying in Switzerland - this will make sense, I promise you. I'm admiring the library of the theological faculty in Bern, a great powerhouse of the Reformation, and I notice something very odd. There are sections on God as Creator, on Jesus, with lots of learned tomes to their credit. But there is no section on the Spirit.
Moreover, during my theological education in Oxford, I wouldn't have been surprised to overhear that snippet of conversation between Paul and John's disciples in Ephesus all over again: ‘Did you receive the Holy Spirit when you became a believer?' and the cautious response: ‘What do you mean?' or even, ‘What on earth are you talking about?'
Of course, both Paul and the Ephesians came to Christianity while they were adults - in that first generation there could be no inherited faith, but only conversion, a new way of understanding God, one growing out of Judaism but which most Jews did not take as their own. Many of us here in St Andrew's, on the other hand, have grown up in the church from being baptised as small children, and may not be able to remember a time when God was not a part of life.
Yet it is not only a question of the once-born versus the twice-born Christians, with the latter emphasising the Spirit's role in conversion. While some Pentecostalist and Evangelical churches have emphasised God's Spirit so much that speaking in tongues, for instance, has almost become a badge of membership, I suspect that some of our tradition, in reaction, may have battened down the hatches on anything pious or enthusiastic, for fear of hypocrisy. Yet if that is so, we are making a grave mistake. For it is God's Spirit, working within us, that gives us the ability to follow Jesus in doing God's will. Church life would be impossible without the Spirit's fruits of love, joy, peace, gentleness, patience and self-control. And without the Spirit leading us into more truth, we would have no hope of growing in understanding of God, ourselves and one another.
Why then is the Spirit, like the idea of full immersion baptism, sometimes regarded with great suspicion in our tradition? Well, in both cases there is likely to be some disruption and messiness involved. Paul wasn't content with breaking in on twelve Ephesians' perfectly satisfactory understanding of faith gained from John the Baptist, giving them a new experience they had neither sought nor demanded of him. There was more to come.
To begin with all went well for Paul and this new faith he preached. When the Ephesian synagogue grew fed up with him, he hired a lecture hall and carried on there, taking his disciples with him. Miracles of healing and exorcism took place, and many came to join him. But not everyone was happy. Ephesus was known for its temple of Artemis, and for the silver images of the goddess which were sold there, and the silversmiths began to see their custom drying up, as more turned away from the worship of Artemis. Trade unrest ended up in a full-scale riot, from which Paul was extricated with difficulty.
And that's true more generally. God's Spirit cannot be relied upon to stay in the realms of religion. Economics and politics are also the Spirit's territory, and where economic and political powers are challenged by God's power, conflict is inevitable. Sadly, when Christians cannot agree, the Spirit may be used as an argument on both sides, in a way that might make us keen to keep away from pious enthusiasm altogether.
But that, again, would be the wrong reaction - as if an immigrant to Britain were to say, ‘I can't speak English very well, so I'll stay among my own people where I don't have to try too hard.' We are all immigrants into God's kingdom, all beginners in learning to listen to God's Spirit, and discernment is the gift of telling God's Spirit from others. So rather than stopping our ears, in case we get confused or into trouble, let's listen out for the Spirit; in the great events of our lives, like baptism, when we can see God and the world in a new light, but also in the little day-to-day things that inspire us to give God thanks. And let's share what we hear with one another. For God's spirit speaks to us not only through the Bible or through great theologians, but also when two or three of us are gathered together, wanting to do God's will. So if you have a quiet feeling that we in this church should be focussing on some particular activity, share it - for others with the same feeling may be waiting for you to speak up. And though the Spirit may disrupt our lives, it's only to cleanse and renew us, to make us ready to do God's will and to fit us for God's kingdom.