Psalm 23; John 10:11-18; Acts 4:5-12; 1 John 3:16-24
There it goes again, in our reading from the first letter of John, that dangerous promise that starts our warning bells ringing: ‘If our hearts do not condemn us, we have boldness before God; and we receive from him whatever we ask, because we obey his commandments and do what pleases him.' Oh yeah, you may quietly be thinking. If Christians receive from God whatever they ask, how come we ever have any problems in life? I'd be surprised, if any of you were to tell me, ‘Every time I pray, God sorts out all my difficulties immediately.' It's much more likely to be: ‘I have this worry about my health. I have that worry about my family. I know it's going to go on for years and years, and maybe never be sorted at all. So what's the point of asking God about it? When nothing happens, that'll just make me feel even worse than I already do, as if it's my fault for bothering the Almighty in the first place.' For any time the question of prayer comes up, so does the question of apparently unanswered prayer, and who is to blame for it.
Some of the answers are obvious. If our prayer, however heartfelt, is to win the lottery in order to live the high life, it's fairly obvious we're on our own with that one; similarly, if our heart's desire is to see our enemies get their comeuppance - though that doesn't seem to stop the psalmists asking. But there are more problematic aspects of prayers for healing. Some churches which believe in healing prayer lay the whole responsibility of tangible success on either those praying, or those for whom we pray. If there seems to be no response, it must mean that either or both parties are seriously sinful, and should repent in sackcloth and ashes. But in practice that doesn't work either, as charismatic Christians discovered to their sorrow when the much-loved, much-prayed for Christian author David Watson died of cancer. In truth, we cannot tell what difference prayer will make. Sometimes the problem will be solved. Sometimes we will be given strength to go on, or peace of mind. But from my own experience I know that offering prayer for healing - and intercessory prayer generally - does make a difference; to us, to the situation or to both.
Of course, intercessory prayer is by no means all there is to praying. If our relationship with God, or any of our relationships, were to be based solely on the benefits we received, even if we were asking on behalf of others, it could not endure - for that would mean treating God as a sugar daddy who could only retain our affections by lavish and continual gifts. In our reading from John's Gospel, Jesus offers another view of the connection between God and us: that of shepherd and sheep. While the shepherd is prepared to give up his life in order to protect the sheep, they in their turn must recognise and listen to his voice, so that they know what he wants them to do.
This makes sense for real sheep and shepherds, but it makes sense too in the context of prayer: for our listening to God is as crucial as our trusting God with the difficulties of our lives. ‘Listening' will sometimes be just the right metaphor to use: the still, small voice of conscience, the idea that comes out of nowhere or the unexpected comment of a friend; but it may be seeing, too - the Bible verse that leaps off the page into our heart, or the rugged beauty of the Peaks - or even feeling the touch of a friend. However it comes to us, a vital part of prayer is our readiness to recognise God, not just in the big once-in-a-lifetime spiritual experiences, but also in the everydayness of our lives. For the more we practise listening for our Shepherd's voice, the better we will know both how to follow him and what to ask of him.
And this homeliness of prayer, like the familiar metaphor of shepherd and sheep that Jesus' hearers would see every day on the dusty roads of Galilee, means that our everyday lives can show us how to pray. ‘Hands together, eyes closed' was how I was taught at school, and that's no bad lesson when in prayer we focus on God alone and distance ourselves from the sights and sounds around us. But as our Celtic ancestors tell us, we can also pray through walking through the woods or the city with or without a dog or a camera, attentive to every sight, sound and smell; through the emotions evoked by a favourite piece of music; or even through the dailiness of washing up. For because God chose to become part of our world, everything in creation can remind us to listen out for God.
I wouldn't like you to think that I always find praying easy. I don't. There are times when the little ‘Help me!' arrow prayers - you know, the ones when you don't know what to do - are as close as I get to praying all day. Sometimes, when my spirit is dry or there's something in myself I don't want to face, turning to God feels the hardest and most boring thing in the world. Yet when I'm like that, I remind myself that God wants the truth of how we are, not the false mask of how we think we should be; and that even wanting to want to pray is still a prayer that God will hear.
Sadly, some books about prayer seem to leave out awkward bits of life like that: boredom, anxiety, even terror. But that's not a mistake our psalmist would make. It's no accident that Psalm 23, one of the most pastoral of psalms, with its imagery of green pastures and still waters, is also one of the most requested readings at funerals, either in the King James version or as the metrical psalm sung to Crimond. For this psalm does not pull its punches. It is in the valley of the shadow of death that the psalmist looks for - and finds - God's guiding hand. It is in the presence of enemies that he finds God's nourishment.
And that is true also for prayer. It can be easy to pray when our hearts are full of gratitude and there's a spring in our step. It can be much harder even to want to remember God when our hearts are full of sorrow or our bodies creak and groan, for it is easy to fear, deep down, either that we have brought disaster on ourselves and are being punished by God, or that God cannot care about us - or why would this terrible thing, whatever it is, happen to us or those we love?
Yet in my experience it can be in those moments of fear and fatigue that God can get through to us: in those times when we know, however much we should like to do so, that we cannot manage on our own; when we have to admit to God our weakness and our need. And when we truly know our need of God, when we are no longer able to pretend to others or to ourselves that all is well in our world, that is when God is able to come to our aid: not necessarily with a conventional happy ending - think of Gethsemane! - but with the strength to take us through whatever the day may bring.
This I believe.