Sermon:
Where were we in the story?
I wonder how you experienced that story. I have to admit that just preparing the script for this service almost moved me to tears; the horrid inevitability of the death of someone I love. Yet Jesus' death wasn't inevitable. Had his friends not forsaken him, had the Jewish authorities not handed him over to Rome, had the crowds not changed their tune, had the soldiers refused to do their job... at every point, had things gone otherwise, he might not have died.
That conclusion reminds me of all too many recent enquiries into the deaths of children or vulnerable adults. Had social workers insisted on seeing and speaking to children rather than listening to the reassurances of those who should have cared for them; had there been a bed available in the specialist unit or a voice at the other end of the support phone-line; had different agencies better communicated with one another... that tragedy might not have occurred. In such circumstances, our next inevitable question is: so who's to blame? Whose head will roll so we can feel that at least this deadly pitfall will be avoided in future situations? Who will become the scapegoat, the example to make others in similar positions take note and amend their ways?
That question has been asked of Jesus' death, too. For centuries, the whole Jewish nation was blamed for his crucifixion. Yet accounts like that of Luke, wanting to present the Christianity of his time as a positive religion which in no way threatened the Roman Empire, actually spun the events of history; for in the time of Jesus only the Romans had the power to crucify their enemies. And such spinning led, however unintentionally, to horrifying persecution of Jews through subsequent centuries culminating in the Holocaust; and, even further, to persecution by the Israeli state of Palestinians today.
Blaming other people tends to land us in that sort of ethical mess. It might be more worthwhile for us to ask ourselves: if I had been in that situation, how much better or worse might I have fared? What decisions might I have taken?
* Am I prone, as one of Jesus' friends, to admitting to knowledge of him only when other Christians are around?
* Am I defensive about my own tradition, and likely to give short shrift to any brash youngster who sees things differently and says so?
* Am I just doing my job, keeping my head down, and not asking too many questions about whether what I'm told to do is right?
* If things go wrong for me, am I liable to turn around and blame others for the predicament I'm in?
* Am I one of the crowd: following the lead of whoever spoke last, happy to go along with whatever as long as I keep my friends?
Or am I someone who tells the truth, even if what I see goes against my expectations? * Am I someone who'll offer my resources with great generosity even if it puts me in danger? * Am I someone who won't be put off supporting a friend however bad things get?
If you get a quiet moment during this holy week, I invite you to consider: where do I find myself in the Passion story? And I invite you, whether in thanksgiving or in confession, to share those thoughts with God.